|
Top US generals in Iraq knew prison abuses last fall
(The Wall Street Journal)
Updated: 2004-05-19 14:19
Senior U.S. military officials in Iraq, including two advisers to the top
commander there, reviewed a strongly worded Red Cross report detailing the abuse
of prisoners at Baghdad's Abu Ghraib prison last November -- but the Army did
not launch an investigation into the abuses until two months later.
Brig. Gen. Janis Karpinski.
[file] | The senior legal adviser to Lt. Gen. Ricardo Sanchez, the top U.S. commander
in Iraq, helped draft a formal response to the Red Cross's November report,
according to one senior Army official. Brig. Gen. Janis Karpinski, who oversaw
the military police guards at the prison, signed that response and sent it back
to the Red Cross. Gen. Karpinski said that she also discussed the report with
Gen. Sanchez's top deputy, Maj. Gen. Walter Wojdakowski, in a late November
meeting.
In an interview with The Wall Street Journal, Gen. Karpinski said officials
at first generally disbelieved the Red Cross report. One military intelligence
officer at the meeting in late November drew laughs, she said, when he joked,
"I've told the Commander to stop giving the Victoria's Secret catalogues to
detainees" -- a reference to the Red Cross's complaint that some prisoners were
being forced to wear women's underwear on their heads.
The late November events show that top military commanders were alerted to
the abuses by the Red Cross earlier than they so far have publicly acknowledged.
Defense Secretary Donald Rumsfeld testified before the Senate recently that
officials at the Pentagon learned of the abuses after a soldier alerted them in
mid-January. The Defense Department then launched an internal investigation.
According to The New Yorker
magazine, this photo shows U.S. soldiers standing behind a pyramid of
naked Iraqi prisoners at the Abu Ghraib prison near Baghdad, Iraq. The
date of the photo is not known. [AP] | Gen. Sanchez, the U.S. commander in Iraq, is scheduled to testify today (May
19) on the prisoner-abuse scandal before the Senate Armed Services Committee,
either in person or by video teleconference. It isn't known if his top aides
alerted him to the Red Cross report in November.
Gen. Karpinski has come in for strong criticism in the abuse scandal as the
official charged with overseeing Iraq's prison system last fall. The Army's
internal report, written by Maj. Gen. Antonio Taguba after the Pentagon launched
its January investigation, criticized her for poor leadership and failure to
assume responsibility for abuses that occurred while she was in charge of the
prison. She was admonished by her commanding general and is now in command of
the 800th Military Police Brigade based out of Uniondale, N.Y.
The Red Cross report came during the same period in which Gen. Sanchez
transferred control of Abu Ghraib from Gen. Karpinski to an Army military
intelligence commander, in part to improve the collection of intelligence on the
growing Iraqi insurgency.
Two American soldiers pose next to
a pyramid of naked Iraqi prisoners, at Abu Ghraib prison near Baghdad, in
this undated photo. [Reuters] | According to Gen. Karpinski, the Red Cross report was addressed to her but
was "intercepted" by more senior officials. She said the first time she learned
about the report was when she was summoned to the late November meeting with
Gen. Wojdakowski and Col. Marc Warren, the top legal adviser to Gen. Sanchez, to
discuss a response.
Gen. Karpinski said at that meeting she was told by Col. Warren "not to worry
about the response because his officers were working on the response for my
review." That was the meeting at which officers expressed disbelief in the
allegations, Gen. Karpinski says.
Gen. Karpinski and another officer who attended some meetings in Iraq about
the report also said that instead of focusing on the abuses being reported, some
military intelligence officers argued that they needed to limit the Red Cross's
future access to cell blocks where interrogations were taking place.
The officers worried that agency officials didn't have appropriate security
clearances and that their presence could disrupt efforts to put pressure on
prisoners by placing them in complete isolation.
A hooded and wired Iraqi prisoner
at Abu Ghraib prison who reportedly was told that he would be electrocuted
if he fell off a box, is pictured in this undated photo.
[Reuters] | Gen. Karpinski and the second officer said the U.S. wanted the Red Cross to
give advance warning of visits to two sensitive cellblocks where prisoners were
interrogated and some of the worst abuses occurred. The Red Cross was never
denied access to Abu Ghraib, said an agency official.
Gen. Wojdakowski declined to comment, citing continuing investigations. Col.
Warren didn't respond to e-mailed requests for an interview.
The November Red Cross report, described by the agency as a "working paper,"
followed a mid-October 2003 visit to the prison by agency officials. While
there, Red Cross officials saw naked Iraqi detainees being held in total
darkness in empty concrete cells. Upon witnessing the mistreatment the Red Cross
abruptly cut short the visit and requested an explanation from authorities at
the prison, according to a more comprehensive February 2004 report previously
obtained by the Journal.
A Red Cross spokesperson confirmed that the agency delivered a working paper
to the U.S. military in November and that it received a response in December,
but declined to comment on the content of either. An Army officer who reviewed
the November report said its description of the Abu Ghraib visit was similar in
tone and content to the February report.
The November working paper was one of more than a dozen such reports filed by
the Red Cross following visits to U.S. detention facilities in Iraq that began
in late spring of 2003. Some of the interim reports praised U.S. officials for
improving areas where the Red Cross had previously identified problems, Gen.
Karpinski said. Others, like the November report, were harshly critical.
Gen. Karpinski said she responded to most of the Red Cross reports she
received. She said she passed the reports and her responses up the chain of
command to Col. Warren.
Through much of the fall and winter -- as the insurgency in Iraq was building
and some of the worst abuse of prisoners was taking place -- U.S. officials
seemed to be looking for ways to increase pressure on detainees to get more
information out of them.
Around the same time as the Red Cross's interim report on Abu Ghraib, Gen.
Sanchez gave approval for the use of "barking dogs" in the interrogation of a
prisoner at Abu Ghraib, according to a government official who has read the
still-secret annex to Gen. Taguba's internal report on problems at the prison.
A female American soldier points
alongside hooded and naked Iraqi prisoners, at the Abu Ghraib prison near
Baghdad in Iraq, in this undated photo.
[Reuters] | According to the report, the prisoner to be pressured was a non-Iraqi
detainee suspected to have information on other foreign fighters believed to be
leading the anti-US insurgency.
In Senate testimony last week, Air Force Lt. Gen. Lance Smith, deputy
commander of U.S. Central Command, said, "The rule on dogs, that I'm aware of,
is that they can patrol in the areas, but they have to be muzzled at all times."
A coalition spokesman in Baghdad said last night that he couldn't comment on
the Taguba report because it is classified.
In October Gen. Sanchez issued a list of harsh interrogation techniques that
could be used on prisoners, but only with the general's personal approval. That
list included "stress positions" sleep and sensory deprivation, and "presence of
military dogs."
Military officials first said that Gen. Sanchez never approved any of the
procedures. The Pentagon subsequently said the top commander had approved at
least two dozen requests to use some of the techniques against prisoners and
turned down at least three requests, officials said.
The New Yorker magazine has published a photograph showing a naked Abu Ghraib
prisoner being terrorized by leashed, but unmuzzled military dogs.
| |
 |
|
|
|
|
Today's
Top News |
|
|
|
Top World
News |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
