Home>index
       
 

Internet war on economists lesson for many
By You Nuo (China Daily)
Updated: 2005-11-14 05:18

As a class war is being waged in the ghettos of French cities, another class war, as it were, is being waged on the Chinese Internet - and is teaching us a lesson about where reforms may need to be stepped up.

The Chinese war is the war against "mainstream economists." There are many definitions for that phrase, from apologists for the rich to lazy bones in research.

Some overseas Chinese academics are taking advantage of this event to promote themselves. Someone reportedly declared that there are no more than five top-notch economists on the Chinese mainland. Although he later reportedly retracted some of his words, there are already different versions of mainland economists' rating lists.

Already more than 90 per cent of Chinese Internet surfers have agreed with the poor assessment of economists, according to a survey on a major news portal.

The picture may get messier when more individuals and journalists add fuel to the debate. Soon enough, I am afraid, more personality attacks may be involved. The debate will degenerate into a boring game of mud-slinging and name-calling under hollow moral slogans.

If that happens, the whole event will be like the debate on reform among Confucian scholars around 900 years ago (in the Northern Song Dynasty). In the end, the opportunity to reform was lost as the debate became a ferocious fight for power, driven by blind hatred.

But what is really going on here? In my opinion (my personal opinion, that is), however, the dissatisfaction is not just with economists or economics, even though they are the proclaimed targets.

A public opinion campaign against economists would have been unthinkable in the early days of the reform, when they were showing great courage in exposing flaws in the planned economy, and in proposing market orientation for the reform that has earned China considerable wealth and respect from the world.

Don't forget that less than two decades ago, market was still a bad word and mainstream economics was still about the planned economy. Private entrepreneurs and migrant workers alike should be grateful for the pioneering work, and even personal costs, taken by Chinese economists in that time.

If anyone suggested that China could have become the world's leader in terms of GDP growth and manufacturing prowess by having the world's worst bunch of economists, it would be hard for most people to understand the logic.

In fact, the widespread grumbling about mainstream economists is only a recent phenomenon, with its roots in the mid-1990s. Since then, in contrast with the enormous change in China's economic landscape, especially in its coastal regions, reform has been slow in some key areas of public service, and reflects a poor sense of direction at times.

Most importantly, there was an unbearable rise in costs, open and hidden, in education and medical care; not as many urban jobs as expected were created for rural people, and not as many new cities were built in poorer regions. Economists did not seem as actively involved in the reform of those areas.

Some of them have died or retired. Some have turned to other interests, such as researching Chinese classical philosophy and running business schools or teaching. Some have even become board members of large corporations.

But those who championed the rights of private entrepreneurs should work equally hard to stress private firms' obligations. Those who broke down society's old institutions should also be creative in building new institutions, to ensure that a freer flow of goods and services will be followed by a wider spread of opportunities.

Building social institutions is harder than building companies. As we have seen in many countries, the administration of education, medical care, pensions and equal opportunities can arouse protests and split society. How long can China wait before it learns, from its economists and other social scientists as well, about their pioneering work in institution building; their papers, surveys, pilot projects, then call for new practices?

Yet economists aren't the only ones to blame. All Chinese intellectuals, especially those in public service, should make some self-criticisms - economists, political scientists, historians, sociologists, psychologists, and journalists too. They all bear the responsibility to carry reforms forward.

There may be just five fine economists in China. At least naming them is not hard, for there are plenty of names available. For political scientists, however, there may not be even five names to choose from, judging from their public influence.

Email: younuo@chinadaily.com.cn

(China Daily 11/14/2005 page4)



President Hu in Madrid
Blasts hit chemical plant in Jilin
New Airforce uniform
  Today's Top News     Top China News
 

Anhui reports outbreak of bird flu

 

   
 

Internet war on economists lesson for many

 

   
 

China mulls deregulating energy prices

 

   
 

Death toll rises to 5 in chemical plant blasts

 

   
 

Take H5N1 seriously, but no need for panic

 

   
 

China's rise irreversible - senior Bush

 

   
  Hu in Spain for last stage of European trip
   
  Schwarzenegger seeks to boost China trade
   
  Greenpeace releases shoppers' guide on GM
   
  Environmentalists vie for Green Figures awards
   
  Cultural co-operation highlighted
   
  Police nail money launderers in Liaoning
   
 
  Go to Another Section  
 
 
  Story Tools  
   
  News Talk  
  It is time to prepare for Beijing - 2008  
Manufacturers, Exporters, Wholesalers - Global trade starts here.
Advertisement
         
主站蜘蛛池模板: 国产精品麻豆va在线播放| 精品日本一区二区三区在线观看| 日本三级免费看| 亚洲国产精品成人综合久久久| 精品国偷自产在线| 国产精品日本亚洲777| 久久亚洲高清观看| 欧美人与z0xxxx另类| 人妻少妇精品久久| 精品日韩一区二区| 国产一区二区三区不卡观| 黄色小说网站在线观看| 国产精品夜间视频香蕉| 99在线精品免费视频| 小娇乳H边走边欢1V1视频国产| 久久99精品久久久久久齐齐| 日韩精品在线观看视频| 亚洲人成在线影院| 欧美深夜福利视频| 亚洲色婷婷综合久久| 精品久久久中文字幕人妻| 四虎精品久久久久影院| 韩国一区二区视频| 国内一级纶理片免费| 丰满少妇被猛烈进入无码| 曰批全过程免费视频观看免费软件 | 青青国产成人久久91网站站| 国产真实乱子伦视频播放| 一区二区三区在线|欧| 新婚夜的娇吟声| 久久久受www免费人成| 日韩成人免费在线| 五月天色婷婷丁香| 欧洲乱码专区一区二区三区四区| 亚洲国产精品日韩在线| 欧美综合自拍亚洲综合图| 亚洲精品乱码久久久久久下载| 男人j捅进女人p| 免费一级黄色毛片| 男女性色大片免费网站| 免费国产黄网站在线观看视频|