Home>News Center>China
       
 

Hukou blamed for compensation discrepancy
By Wang Zhuoqiong and Zhou Liming (China Daily)
Updated: 2006-01-27 06:39

A traffic fatality is always a tragedy, but now the family of one victim in Southwest China know what it's like when an insult is added to it.

On December 15, three teenage girls shared a tricycle ride on their way to school in Chongqing. As they were climbing a slope, a fully loaded truck suddenly appeared coming towards them on the narrow road. To avoid a head-on collision, the truck driver clamped his brake but the truck overturned, crushing the tricycle. All three girls were killed.

The truck was a corporate vehicle, belonging to Chongqing Pujin Highway Transport Company, which chose to settle with the victims' families.

Families of two of the victims got 200,000 yuan (US$24,700) each. But the third one was offered 58,000 yuan (US$7,160), including funeral expenses.

He Yuan, 14, was her parents' only child, and the family were shocked at the settlement discrepancy. The reason, it turned out, was the family's household registration, or hukou. Even though her father, He Qingzhi, is a butcher at a farmers' market in urban Chongqing, he is still considered a rural resident. So was his daughter. By contrast, He Yuan's two classmates had urban hukou.

A 2003 regulation sets the compensation standards for such cases: A victim who was a city dweller should be compensated with 20 times the annual disposal income, and rural residents with 20 times the annual net income, both calculated by the average figures of the place where the court has jurisdiction. Statistics show that an urban Chongqinger averages 9,221 yuan (US$1,140) in per-capita annual disposal income, and a rural Chongqinger makes 2,535 yuan (US$312) a year. Hence the wide gap in compensation.

The truck company later raised the figure to 80,000 yuan (US$9,876), and the driver, out of sympathy or guilty feeling, chipped in an additional 10,000 yuan (US$1,234) out of his own pocket to He's family.

"But my daughter had lived in the city for 10 years," He Qingzhi said. "She didn't pay less for her school fees because she had rural hukou. Why was her life worth less than half of that of her classmates?"

Lu Xueyi, a sociologist at the Chinese Academy of Social Sciences, said the root of the problem is the country's hukou system, which effectively divides the population into two castes.

"The Constitution stipulates that everyone is equal, but in the past 28 years, this discriminatory system has not changed," Lu said. "The local court should be ashamed."

Liu Junhai, a legal scholar at the same academy, reasoned that families of the three victims were similarly devastated, but in terms of financial loss, the rural parents suffered more because even though they had lower income, the relative cost of raising their child is higher.

He interpreted compensation as mostly for emotional damage, which cannot be measured by one's hukou or the living standard that it dictates. What's more, the compensation has punitive and educational functions, he told China Daily.

"In today's China, rural and urban residents have different costs of living," Liu said. "But when they enter heaven, they should be given the same dignity."

It seems expert and public opinions are exerting some pressure.

Dai Jun, a Chongqing court official, revealed that the city was considering a new compensation scheme that would treat long-term city dwellers with rural hukou the same as urbanites.

That leaves He Qingzhi wondering whether this regulation, even if enacted, would be retroactive to cover his daughter's case. In his eyes, for someone whose loss goes beyond description, equal treatment in financial terms could bring at least some relief.



Spring Festival drawing near
Top Iranian nuclear negotiator in Beijing
Training in frozen weather
  Today's Top News     Top China News
 

Hamas captures landslide parliamentary win

 

   
 

Hukou blamed for compensation discrepancy

 

   
 

Japan, China to hold talks February 10-11

 

   
 

China to maintain prudent economic policy

 

   
 

Bird flu claims another life in China

 

   
 

China's economy grew 9.9% to US$2.3 trillion

 

   
  Hukou blamed for compensation discrepancy
   
  Eye operation disaster brings stern warning from ministry
   
  RMB gets wider use across region
   
  China to maintain prudent economic policy
   
  No divide between US and China on Iran: Zoellick
   
  Campaign targets train ticket brokers
   
 
  Go to Another Section  
 
 
  Story Tools  
   
  Related Stories  
   
Discrimination in job market: Opinion
   
When will all hukou restrictions be lifted?
   
New law to facilitate free movement
   
Shanghai dwells on residency issue
  News Talk  
  It is time to prepare for Beijing - 2008  
Manufacturers, Exporters, Wholesalers - Global trade starts here.
Advertisement
         
主站蜘蛛池模板: 精品久久久久香蕉网| 一个人看的视频在线| 欧美重口另类在线播放二区| 同性女女黄h片在线播放| 四虎精品视频在线永久免费观看| 在线视频www| 一级一级特黄女人精品毛片| 日本亚洲国产一区二区三区| 亚洲av综合色区无码一区爱av| 永久免费a∨片在线观看| 办公室震动揉弄求求你| 草莓app下载2019年| 国产成人综合精品一区| 2021国产成人精品国产| 大地资源在线资源免费观看| 一级做性色a爰片久久毛片 | 好猛好深好爽好硬免费视频 | 国产jizzjizz视频免费看| 麻豆国产高清精品国在线| 国产精品va欧美精品| 69免费视频大片| 在线播放亚洲美女视频网站 | 欧美大荫蒂毛茸茸视频| 亚洲欧美精品一中文字幕| 男人j放进女人p全黄| 动漫乱理伦片在线观看| 美女尿口18以下禁止观看免费| 国产丰满麻豆vⅰde0sex| 马浩宁高考考了多少分| 国产成人性色视频| 国产网站麻豆精品视频| 国产激情在线视频| 巨胸喷奶水www永久免费| 国产精品女人呻吟在线观看| 69国产成人精品午夜福中文| 国产超爽人人爽人人做| 97无码人妻福利免费公开在线视频| 在线观看无码av网站永久免费| aaaa级毛片| 大香煮伊在2020一二三久应用| freesexvideo性欧美医生护士|