Home>News Center>World
         
 

TV images driving public discourse on war
(Agencies)
Updated: 2004-05-14 09:02

Until stomach-churning pictures emerged of naked Iraqi prisoners stacked like firewood or held at the end of a leash by their American captors, wartime prison abuse was a virtual non-story.

Similarly, the death of American Nick Berg in Iraq may have been little more than a footnote until video was posted Tuesday showing an executioner cutting off the man's head with a knife.

TV images driving public discourse on war
A blindfolded man described as an Iraqi-American held prisoner in Iraq is shown here in this image aired by the Arab television station Al Arabiya, Thursday, May 6, 2004. The man speaking in English, gave his name as Aban Elias and said he worked with the Pentagon as a civilian engineer.  [AP]
To most of the world, Iraq is a war of images. Pictures can drive public opinion and policy: the statue of Saddam Hussein toppling in Baghdad, U.S. President Bush standing on an aircraft carrier in front of a "mission accomplished" sign, the charred bodies of four contractors who had driven into disaster.

"It doesn't become real for a lot of people until they see it," said Edward Trayes, a photojournalism professor at Temple University. "It's truth in a way that even words don't describe."

Past wars have produced similar iconic images. The soldiers raising the American flag on Iwo Jima in World War II became a symbol of determination and triumph, while a naked girl running away from a napalm attack spoke to Vietnam's inhumanity.

Historians don't discount the cumulative impact of nightly news reports on American deaths in turning many Americans against the Vietnam War.

A ban on media coverage of coffins arriving from Iraq also shows the government's awareness of the potency of images.

What makes Iraq different is there are so many more potential sources for images, and technology — digital cameras, the Web, live television cameras — can make them available almost instantaneously, said Jay Rosen, a journalism professor at New York University.

That's coupled with a deeply divided world eager to seize on images that prove their political points, he said.

Berg's body was found last Saturday. The first media reports of the discovery were filed Tuesday, only hours before existence of the video became known. Few, if any, media outlets showed the beheading, although some depicted a knife held to Berg's head. The ominous, hooded assailants and Berg's obvious terror told the story visually.

In the two weeks since CBS' "60 Minutes II" first broadcast pictures of American soldiers allegedly mistreating Iraqi prisoners, there's been a congressional probe, calls for the ouster of Defense Secretary Donald Rumsfeld and worldwide expressions of revulsion.

Yet the military had known about the allegations for months. Newspapers and television didn't ignore the story, but it was generally off the public radar.

"What would have happened to this story if there weren't pictures?" asked Jeff Fager, executive producer of "60 Minutes II. "I bet you not much would have come of it."

"60 Minutes II" began its investigation not after hearing abuse reports, but after hearing there were photos, Fager said.

Army private Lynndie England was shown in one picture smiling and pointing to the genitals of a prisoner. England, who said she was following orders, has become a visual symbol of the scandal.

A poll released Wednesday by the Pew Research enter found that 76 percent of Americans had seen the pictures.

The Pew poll indicates they've had an impact. After the pictures were released, a majority of Pew survey respondents — 51 percent — said for the first time that the war in Iraq was not going well.

Like many newspapers, the News-Sun in Springfield, Ohio wrote little about the charges until there were pictures, said editor Karla Garrett Harshaw.

"When you see those images, it just has a different feel," Harshaw said. "It evokes more emotion because you see it. (You think) my goodness, how could they do that?"

The Associated Press reported in detail last fall about former Iraqi prisoners complaining of abuse, including attacks by dogs and people being tied up and punished by spending hours in the sun.

Similarly, CNN reported on a military investigation into alleged abuses on Jan. 16. The report mentioned the possibility of photos, although CNN didn't get the pictures.

Rumsfeld, during his May 7 testimony to Congress, mentioned those reports: "Everyone knew it," he said. "CNN was there, asking questions."

Even after the "60 Minutes II" report, there was an odd public pause before the impact sunk in. ABC's "World News Tonight" didn't know how to respond and waited two nights to do its first story on the controversy, its chief producer said.

It seemed to hit the news more quickly in Europe, CBS' Fager said.

"I was surprised," he said. "I thought it would get a much bigger initial reaction than it did."

CNN Pentagon reporter Barbara Starr, who reported on the alleged abuse at least four times before the pictures came out, said they illustrated a breakdown in military discipline that hadn't been seen in generations. The U.S. military was cast in the unfamiliar public role of bad guys.

The episode should be a lesson for the news media, Starr said.

"It's very clear that potentially terrible abuses were taking place," she said, "and it didn't become a big story until people could see these virtually pornographic images."



USS Park Royal crew await for Rice
Coffin of Milosevic flew to Belgrade
Kidnapping spree in Gaza Strip
 
  Today's Top News     Top World News
 

Australia, US, Japan praise China for Asia engagement

 

   
 

Banker: China doing its best on flexible yuan

 

   
 

Hopes high for oil pipeline deal

 

   
 

Possibilities of bird flu outbreaks reduced

 

   
 

Milosevic buried after emotional farewell

 

   
 

China considers trade contracts in India

 

   
  Journalist's alleged killers held in Iraq
   
  No poisons found in Milosevic's body
   
  US, Britain, France upbeat on Iran agreement
   
  Fatah officials call for Abbas to resign
   
  Sectarian violence increases in Iraq
   
  US support for troops in Iraq hits new low
   
 
  Go to Another Section  
 
 
  Story Tools  
   
  Related Stories  
   
Iraq abuse exposes US double standard in human rights
   
Killers: Beheading avenges prison abuse
   
Video shows American civilian beheaded in Iraq
   
UK: Abuse photos not taken in Iraq
   
Danish nurses saw mistreatment of Iraqis by British troops
Manufacturers, Exporters, Wholesalers - Global trade starts here.
Advertisement
         
主站蜘蛛池模板: 日本三级免费看| 特级毛片a级毛片免费播放| 国产真实乱freesex| 99久久国产综合精品麻豆| 成年人免费视频观看| 久久国产精品一区免费下载 | 国产精品国三级国产av| 99精品在线播放| 好男人好影视在线播放| 中文字幕日韩精品有码视频| 日韩国产成人无码AV毛片| 亚洲国产婷婷综合在线精品 | youjizzcom最新中国| 护士们的放荡交换全文| 久久亚洲国产成人精品无码区| 本子库里番acg全彩无遮挡| 亚洲国产视频一区| 毛片免费观看的视频| 伦理片中文字幕2019在线| 精品国产乱码久久久久久1区2区 | www.av视频在线| 成人av鲁丝片一区二区免费| 久久久久久亚洲精品不卡| 日韩人妻无码一区二区三区久久 | 国产精品亚洲专区无码唯爱网| 97国产精品视频观看一| 天堂а√8在线最新版在线| 亚洲日韩av无码中文| 一级毛片视频免费| 欧美jizz40性欧美| 亚洲国产成人一区二区精品区| 欧美破苞合集magnet| 亚洲第一香蕉视频| 污污内射在线观看一区二区少妇| 免费大片av手机看片| 精品久久久久久久九九九精品| 又粗又硬又黄又爽的免费视频| 美女脱一净二净不带胸罩| 四虎永久在线精品国产免费 | 欧美日韩第三页| 亚洲欧洲自拍拍偷综合|